Pleasantly surprised with Brian Kilmeade and Don Yaeger’s history of the Battle of New Orleans, I recently decided to listen to an audiobook recording of their 2016 book Thomas Jefferson and the Tripoli Pirates: The Forgotten War That Changed American History. Like most people, I knew little about the First Barbary War (1801-1805) and figured this might make for a fast-moving overview of the conflict and lead to a better understanding of its context and lasting impact on America’s development. After listening to it, however, I feel like I got a distorted version of the real story in a muddled, unevenly paced narrative that attempts to explain the events of the conflict through a distinctly modern lens.
The war the book discusses is indeed one of our most forgotten conflicts, its causes, course, and results little known or understood. Yet it ranks as a landmark event in the history of our republic, it being the first international conflict in which the young United States had a chance to establish itself as a world power. As strange as it sounds to us today living in the era in which our nation is the world’s lone true superpower, there was a time in which rogue nations such as the Barbary states (Morocco, Algiers, Tunis, and Tripoli, at the time newly independent from long years of Ottoman rule) routinely preyed on American shipping in the Mediterranean and forced us to pay tribute for passage in international waters at the peril of the seizure of our ships and crewmen. Our young government was seemingly unable to stop the practice in the first decades of nationhood, and the circumstance threatened our standing if not our very sovereignty. We at long last mustered the resources and resolve to challenge the Barbary pirates during the administration of Thomas Jefferson in the form of a specially-created fleet and military forces sent to the region to enforce American rights. Our victories on land and sea in combat with the Tripolitans are forever immortalized in the Marine’s Hymn:
“From the Halls of Montezuma,
To the Shores of Tripoli,
We will fight our country’s battles
In the air, on land, and sea;”
The tale revealed in the pages of Kilmeade and Yaeger’s book is at times fascinating and enlightening. I will admit that since I knew very little of the travails of the American sailors and ships in that region and the difficulty with which we finally brought our military might to bear or the ways that victory helped launch a new era of American naval power, it did help me understand a formative era of our nation’s past. But Kilmeade and Yaeger seem to want to cast the events they chronicle in the light of our modern-day difficulties in that region, somehow conflating the Barbary Wars (we were ultimately in a state of armed conflict for over a decade) as part of a continuity of strained relations with Islamic states. They offer up the Barbary War as a sort of proof of old axiom about history repeating itself and suggest forcing a link between eighteenth century Mediterranean pirates and Middle East terrorists which I fail to grasp. Since listening to the book I have found other reviewers who know far more than I do question some of their conclusions and even their understanding of some of the evidence they use to make their arguments. In summary, if you want to know more about the Barbary Wars and their significance, I would suggest you look elsewhere.
JMB