The decades between 1830s and the 1870s are perhaps the most pivotal defining period of Southern history. Within the span of those forty years the region witnessed unprecedented development, became especially embroiled in an international war, underwent a transformative political upheaval that resulted in secession, waged and suffered defeat in a bloody civil war, and endured the long, difficult period we today call Reconstruction. The career of John Forsyth, Jr., a leading Southern journalist and political figure who made his home in Mobile, Alabama, and Columbus, Georgia, coincides perfectly with this defining epoch in regional history. More than that, Forsyth, through his influence, voice, and connections, played an important role in understanding, reflecting, and at times forming opinion and reaction to some of the most important events of his time.
If the name doesn’t ring a bell, you are not alone. One of the most recognizable names of his generation at one time, our memory of him has quickly faded even in the very places he once called home. Rescuing this forgotten figure from contemporary obscurity and vividly illustrating the times in which he lived is Lonnie Burnett’s 2006 biography, The Pen Makes a Good Sword: John Forsyth of the Mobile Register. I’m embarrassed to admit I’ve just gotten around to reading this informative book, as author Burnett (now Dean of the College of Arts and Sciences at the University of Mobile) has long established himself as one of Alabama’s leading historians and since I have also called both Columbus and the Mobile area home his subject’s name is very familiar. Having belatedly read the book cover to cover, I am glad I did.
The book is at once not what one might expect from a biography of a man of letters such as Forsyth and so much more. A newspaper editor for much of his life and a very public figure by virtue of his status as a son of Andrew Jackson’s secretary of state and the offices he held during his esteemed career—such as U.S. Minister to Mexico, state legislator, and mayor of Mobile—much of Forsyth’s career played out in the pages of periodicals of the era rather than in a wealth of private correspondence. On the expansion of slavery, national politics, the pivotal election of 1860, the viability of an independent Southern nation, and the conditions in which the defeated former Confederacy would reenter American political life, Forsyth naturally had much to say. Further, what he did say reflected quite often not just his personal opinion but those of large numbers of his fellow citizens. Because Burnett’s chronicle of his life is traced in large part through his innumerable editorial articles, a variety of types of official correspondence, and the writings of contemporaries who either shared or stood opposed to his views, it is in the end a unique first-hand account of the era as much as the man. Forsyth’s public writings are of course taken with the appropriate grains of salt depending on the situations in which they appeared, mind you, but the book ends up detailing the life of a man playing a leading role in a remarkable age filled with landmark events more than focusing on the inner workings of the man himself.
Few will be disappointed with the result, for Burnett makes Forsyth’s world both tangible and understandable, and illuminates aspects of the times in which Forsyth operated from the perspectives of both the individual and the larger populace. The book is worth a read for this even more than for its revelation of a relatively forgotten figure from the Southern past. The Pen Makes a Good Sword is sure to remain the standard on its subject for a very long time, but its true importance rests upon its broader vision.
JMB