With the publication of These Rugged Days, Alabama’s extraordinary military saga during our nation’s most dramatic trial has finally been told as it has so long deserved. A rich and colorful tale of larger-than-life leaders, colorful personalities civilian and military, and dramatic moments framed by cavalry raids and modestly-sized but deadly battles on land and sea, it is a story that has awaited an able teller for over a century and a half. Aside from the relatively substantial but niche body of literature about the Battle of Mobile Bay, few professional studies chronicle the state’s Civil War battles in any great detail. Even fewer have attempted to paint the broader picture of the shooting war in the Heart of Dixie as a whole. Instead, Alabamians for generations now have had their story of those most pivotal years of 1861-1865 told largely through the lens of battlefield experiences in Virginia, Georgia, and Tennessee, spiced with a smattering of civilian anecdote, or in monographs of less than easy availability. Save for the famous meeting of the man and the hour in Montgomery in 1861 and Farragut’s celebrated exclamation regarding underwater explosive devices in 1864, Alabamians have generally been assured what happened within their state’s borders was either inconsequential or unnecessary, ultimately rendering it all rather forgettable. Enter author John Sledge, an accomplished writer with a lengthy and growing list of accolades and an innate feel for the subject born of familial heritage and decades of study. Through his appreciation for the past of his home state and his smooth, engrossing prose, we finally have a riveting account of Alabama’s Civil War that enlivens obscure figures we should better know, animates forgotten landscapes where war was waged with which we should be more familiar, and brings home the visceral emotion and profound spectacle of combat on Alabama soil and waters through which we should have understood these events all along.
It is indeed one of the supreme ironies in Alabama’s storied history that a state so starkly shaped by the war and so associated with the movement which brought it about has so thin a historiography of its own Civil War experience. As discussed in previous blogs here evaluating some of the timely recent scholarly attention being focused on Alabama’s war years (Civil War Alabama and The Yellowhammer War), there have been few serious studies of the war in the state in modern times, none of them satisfying or enduring. Clearly, the skirmishes, raids, and battles which took place within the state were in no way equivalent to Shiloh or Gettsyburg, but they are actions where men fought and died, had real consequence at the time of their occurrence, and are enduring landmarks in local history for communities from Athens to Spanish Fort and Demopolis to Loachapoka. But in addition to any measure of impact on the war’s trajectory, these events deserve mention for their sheer drama. Alabama’s hallowed grounds include territory on which the “Wizard of the Saddle” (Nathan Bedford Forrest) accomplished some of his most daring feats and had some of his closest calls; beheld the largest naval engagement of the war; provided the backdrop for the largest cavalry force organized during the war; and witnessed the last grand open-field charge of the war. The state not only served as the first capital of the Confederacy, but played a significant part in the logistical operation and supply of its armies to boot. The war also left in its wake epoch-defining destruction, despair, and disorder. Clearly it is a rich story for investigation if ever there was one.
Sledge begins his book by referencing an episode from his childhood, recalling the time when a beloved grandmother recounted for him the story of Wilson’s Raid during a trip from Montevallo to Selma. The story illuminates the author’s own background and alerts the reader to the lens through which he wants us to understand the story he tells, but it also serves to highlight the way so much of Alabama’s Civil War heritage usually has been told—as distinctly personal, local legend brought to life only on special occasions rather than shared statewide experience. His ensuing accounts of the major military actions in the state, ranging from the march of Abel Streight’s “jack ass cavalry” across the hilly, verdant terrain of north Alabama to the thundering artillery duel which took place where the lapping waters of Mobile Bay meet the glimmering Gulf of Mexico during the Battle of Mobile Bay are models of storytelling. Never does Sledge try to overstate significance, but consistently does he communicate real people, places, and events undeservedly forgotten by most Alabamians. The reader comes away with a better understanding of how and why the scattered fighting in the state unfolded as it did, and learns in its course the effect on the communities through which the armies passed. Again, real people, brought to life as living, breathing eyewitnesses, are animated, including among them the swaggering cavalryman Forrest, the bold heroine Emma Sansom, the irrepressible artillerist John Pelham, the salty naval captain Franklin Buchanan, and the patriotic novelist Augusta Jane Evans. But we also hear from lesser-known citizens and journalists, students and planters, businessmen and mothers, free men and slaves. These Rugged Days indeed presents a balanced approach, weaving snapshots of moments in time into a comprehensible tapestry with flair and obvious affection.
I highly recommend the book to anyone interested in Alabama history. It is authoritative but not tedious as an overview guide to the military actions occurring within the state, possessing just enough information on military maneuver to chronicle the combat without bogging the reader into the mire of overly detailed accounts of troop dispositions. It likewise contains just enough civilian perspective to give a convincing taste of Alabama’s distinct homefront flavor without overemphasizing the role of daily routine in a war which was anything but. Sledge is unapologetically writing for the most general of audiences here, and it is to his credit and our benefit. My only quibble would be the absence of some good custom maps through which to better follow the action he describes, but this is nitpicking. As a narrative history of Alabama’s Civil War events, These Rugged Days is unsurpassed and will certainly be the standard on its subject for years to come.
JMB